|
Where to send zines for review:
Everything here is copyright © 2003 by its respective author: either Marc, What’s a zine? To quote Jason Adams (of 1000 Interlocking Pieces, R.I.P.): “Sort of a cross between a magazine and a long letter, mailed to whomever, whenever. The average zine publisher is a loveable nerd with no life. Like Urkel.” Rule number one is always send well-concealed cash. Most every zine you’ll find does not have a checking account (or much business sense, for that matter). Sending a money order from the post office with “Pay to the order of” left blank or stamps is O.K. sometimes, as an alternative. Ask first. Also, international peoples, toss in an extra buck or two. Sometimes it’s a problem if you address a letter to the zine, rather than the publisher, depending upon the whimsy of your random postal worker. All zines reviewed herein were published in the United States of America, unless otherwise noted. For some, in lieu of ca$h money, I traded one or more issues of my own zine. Maybe you could, too. When ordering, please mention to the publishers that you read about them here. All the more free zines for me. Pour out a little liquor.
$? — Sometimes I don’t know the price. Send two bucks and a breezy letter.
I’ll post more reviews next month, maybe. In the meantime (to quote Spacehog) Zine Thug #1 — Twenty-six years and a half in the making, posted a few weeks ago. Ben Joseph meets Violet Jones, bitter pie caught at Starbucks (!), and a chubby girl in a Boston Celtics T-shirt. Sixty-four zines and comics overanalyzed. On deck: MISSING ZINE PERSONS: |
About 10,000 Words (Reviewed by The J Man) 60 pages of fantasy stories, fantasy comics, cultural critique, neighborhood history, poems, game and zine reviews, even dream interpretations. Most of the stuff is worth the time it takes to read (unless you are a slow reader) Bored (Reviewed by The J Man) #2: What can be said about a zine in which a fake advice column question from a fake Christian teen girl who has become addicted to anal sex is its *cleverest* feature? If this were a contestant on American Idol, one could say it was being deliberately stupid to provoke some caustic remark from limey wise ass Simon in order to be on the television The Cheap Vegan (Reviewed by thrill racer) #5 (“The Big DIY issue!”): Cool, I’m a vegan. I
wouldn’t call myself “cheap,” though I’ve been poor enough times to learn to
be resourceful. This issue has recipes for making granola, seitan
(plus recipes for using the seitan including a recipe for barbecue sauce),
soy milk, sushi (I always wondered why supposed vegans told me they ate
sushi when I thought it meant “raw fish,” but I guess not, however, I
don’t go for seafood anyway), pasta, egg roll wrappers, vegan broth, and
nut butter (this one is only “cheaper than store-bought nut butter” if
you can squirrel away free nuts.) Personally, I wouldn’t say these
recipes are about being “cheap,” but rather a culinary artist. Most of
the recipes sound hard, especially “Makin’ Seitan,” and then you’d need
to figure out what you’re going to do with it all. Open a restaurant
maybe! If you calculated the value of your labor and shopping time I
don’t think you’d find the results came cheaply, but you would be living
high on the hog (where did that phrase come from?)! I can buy cheap
wheat pasta at Big Lots, nevertheless, these recipes look pretty cool and
I hope to eventually get a chance to try some of them out. Clutch (Reviewed by Marc) #9. Feeling Good. Ordering this autobio comic is the best all-around move I’ve made in months. Daily diary, with four static panels per diem, and gaping quirks in an otherwise layabout storyline. Like, it is not explained why Clutch’s buddy Fred is given a potato for a torso, or why Fred always carries a doughnut. We can only learn through observation that he does indeed put down the doughnut to cut hair — in this issue Fred is studying to be a barber, and needs practice with the curling iron; not clear is whether he carries it while driving the author around in a borrowed car. I also wonder if Clutch really throws his arms into the air when hearing good news, occasionally adding, “Wahoo!” I bet it’s all too cute in person. This month of entries involves a bit of dancing and a whole lot of sleeping. Vegetarian Clutch (I feel like a goober referring to this guy by his zine’s title when I know his name, but that’s apparently the thing to do) got food poisoning a couple years ago, so “about once a week”, the stasis in his gut requires that he lie down and groan in cursive. Lots of ziney characters here (e.g., there is a “split” involved), so be warned. [$? / mini / 36 pp. / photocopied] Cobweb Junction (Reviewed by Marc) #9, Summer 2001. Markedly able personal zine, but this is the two-year-old farewell issue. Aiko was graduating high school at the time and felt that to be a good enough stopping point. She skips the prom, quotes Salinger and Tom Stoppard, and wishes her butt were “a bit smaller”. Among many other highlights: “I wish I had a cat. They’re so soft and cute and tranquil. I’m not a dog person at all, unless the dog is small, even cat-sized.” And near the end, contemplating the future, she expresses an interest in fake zinery. “I’ve never read a zine by a fictional person, and I think that would be really fun and interesting to do.” Contains photos of the author. Complexification Strategory: A Ten Foot Rule Suppliment (Reviewed by Marc) January 2003. After seeing a tiny portfolio of illustrations he’d done for other people’s zines, I sent Shawn two bucks and some trades, in expectation of reading the comic that led to all this freelance work. In return I got two thin collections of stuff done for other people’s zines. At least, I’d read “Cheap Eats On-the-Road” already in Food Geek, and I have a good idea where else I could find “The Grocery Snob in the Rose City”. This has ten or so short adventures, almost all of them narrated by the author, with his sideburns and soul patch, cargo shorts and Chuck Taylors, in a voice platitudinous as all get-out. There’s one about Pabst Blue Ribbon and how the neo-white trash thing, man, that’s so pretentious. “Since when have you been working class?” Then a couple pages later there’s a strip called “Work”, done like a Soviet propaganda poster and about the author’s ten years of “menial” employment. Shawn worries about earthquakes and nuclear winter (“Now the world is even crazier than before, and I’m not sure what to feel anymore”); much of the dialogue begins with a “dude”. The art is all done without computers, and I can stare at each page for minutes and learn a great deal about inking. But I’ve seen enough. [$1 / digest / 16 pp. / photocopied] Crimewave U.S.A. (Reviewed by The J Man) #14: Mediocre collection mainly consisting of slice-of-life humor pieces. There’s a dog story, notes from a trip to Italy (bits about weird Euro toilets, etc.), a bland interview with David *Mr. Show* Cross (featuring the usual bland interview questions such as “how did you get your job writing for the Ben Stiller Show?”), a story by somebody named Jeff Kay reminiscing about his high school job as a bag boy at grocery store (lots of *wacky* stock boys, managers, butchers, etc. involved in wacky stuff like cutting loud farts in front of customers and a rather unremarkable anecdote about a co-worker who destroys a Doritos display which ends with the author stating “I’ve seen a lot of things in my life, but that was one of the more memorable.” Man, I mean, wouldn’t even a glimpse of a middle-aged housewife in sweatpants and sweatshirt bending down to grab a tube of toothpaste from the bottom shelf be more memorable than a pile of broken Nacho chips? “Life check, aisle 3”), another travel story, this one from Laura Abraham who announces in paragraph two: “I hate people. In fact, I probably hate you. The only thing I hate more than people, are groups of people.” Sure, you hate us. That’s why you feel the need to share your boring travel story with us. In reality, you have deep feelings of inferiority, and a desperate longing to be liked and admired Deviant Technology Superstar (Reviewed by Marc) This scribbly curio is the first zine I received specifically for review here, along with a friendly reminder to keep up with my business. As well, Andrew IM’ed me out of the blue one evening last year, and we discussed pieces of his art, his interpretation of them, and whether or not I would be purchasing a painting (I didn’t). Based on that exchange, I read this with the assumption that Penland could deliver a thesis on what he was trying to say when he cut a long strip of pornographic text from whatever source, tied it around a piece of yarn, and stuck a safety pin through it. And all of it is pasted on top of some other copy. More strips of text and safety pins are knotted to give the impression, perhaps, of two animals copulating; cut up colored paper and ballpoint pen forms a butterfly. Doodles and esoteric poems made with a computer. It’s fun to have around. [$1 / digest / 12 pp. / photocopied] Website: Doris (Reviewed by The J Man) #20: This is the first issue of Doris I have seen The East Village Inky (Reviewed by Marc) #17, October 2002. Thought I’d check this one out after reading a dozen reviews that all read: “Great, if that’s your thing.” Procreation is actually not my thing, but I was there for the whole issue. It’s handwritten, prone to breaking into cartoon, and oh so parenthetical. Articles are concluded arbitrarily then amended with a sarcastic dialogue bubble. So what does issue seventeen hold for Ayun, Inky, Milo, and Greg? Well A Girl and Her Bike (Reviewed by Marc) #8, May 2001. Lots of writing here, almost all of it prose, forced into couplets. What I mean is Angie does this thing where it’s two lines, skip a line, two lines, skip, etc. It takes a few pages to adjust and to stop forcing breaks where they are not. Maybe it isn’t a necessary device (after all, she drops it when needing to be serious, like when watching Sleater Kinney play live), but it (along with some fascinating abuse of the comma) creates a mesmerizing read. Which is good. For quite a stretch, there is a travel journal that includes her attending the first ever ladyfest a few years back, and an overwhelming number of bands I don’t know are discussed. What got me through was the relentless girl-craziness. Like myself, Angie is pushing thirty and not at all gracefully. What I mean is Here (Reviewed by Marc) #6. I saw something not too long ago on CNN, about a mosque in Baghdad, designed by Saddam Hussein himself. Two of its towers look like rifles, two resemble Scud missiles. The correspondent opined how this is clearly a monument to the Gulf War, yet no mention is made of the Iraqi lives lost. Halfway through reading this zine, I made the connection between this and the most famous of U.S. missiles during Operation Desert Storm. “Life During Wartime” reads the front cover of this issue, which was written (or put together, at least — there are lots of contributors) on Sept. 11, 2002, now known as “Patriot Day”. But the subject really only comes up in Neil’s rundown on cable television coverage of the one year anniversary. (Two channels carry the “Wall Street moment of silence, with Spanish voiceover”.) Well, there’s also an article on a reenactment of the Battle of Brooklyn (from the American Revolution [my favorite war!]). Maybe I could’ve read this more astutely and considered some recent events, but I was satisfied as it was with the wit. The subtitle of Here is “The Stories Behind Where You Are”. Somewhat contradictory is the stance on travelogue. The contributors write largely about where they live (largely about local history), but there is one story by a woman from Singapore who hitchhikes around British Columbia. This would be swell, but in another piece, where three white guys from New York discuss gentrification, one of them says how you shouldn’t even bring a camera on vacation, much less write about it. Anyway, their extended conversation over Chinese food was my favorite part. If only white people didn’t have to be around their own kind! “But you’re not a gentrifier”, says one. “You are the frontiersman.” If there has ever been a coffee table zine The Inner Swine (Reviewed by thrill racer) Vol. 8, issue 4, December 2002: The best part of this
page packed zine edited by Jeffrey Somers was the short fiction
(“Time’s Thumb”) about a dude who goes crazy because his mother tried to
poison him and instead of consuming the care packages he let his college
buddies eat them while back home his little fat brother and alcoholic
father never made it out alive. Guilt, shame, and murder—the stuff
compelling stories are made of. ¶ The article I liked next best was “Jeff
Somers’ Running Tour of Chicago” because it’s filled with true facts I
never knew about like descriptions of the products marathon runners buy
(foil blankets and nasty gel treats?!) and insight about “future bride of
the Swine, Legal Counsel Danette Knopp” (she can lift and break Somers
over her knee) and how The Inner Swine’s Inner Circle (TISIC) is a cozy
close knit group that likes to take trips and attend events together.
In articles before this one the reader learns that Somers considers
everyone including himself an asshole and that he’s self obsessed (the
zine even kicks off with fan mail and reprints of his zine’s reviews), but
don’t let the bad attitude fool you; after all, he has friends and a
fiance and even a good job in the publishing industry. Try being a real
outsider and you’ll really know what assholes are about. ¶ The zine’s
theme is “fame” and one article, “Low Rent Internet Fame” (about how the
editor puts more and more articles up on his website to increase his
chances of coming up in people’s Google searches), especially impressed
me because it actually happened to me! One day I was searching for
information about stalkers (and this was before I ever read a copy of The
Inner Swine) and I suddenly found that I had just downloaded an Inner
Swine .pdf file about how Somers wished he had a stalker. It kind of
annoyed me because I was looking for serious information and anyone who’s
ever actually had a stalker knows that it’s neither cute or funny. But
well, that’s “low rent internet fame” for ya! ¶
In conclusion, I think at least one fourth of this zine is interesting
material so definitely check it out! lubb-dupp (Reviewed by thrill racer) Cool, remember that word onomatopoeia? A word that imitates the sound it represents. Anyway, this is a tiny comic zine about Beau Sia and Sailor J, a gay couple who talk about random things. The drawings and writing are kind of abstract and the styles change throughout. I like when they turn into a shark and rhinoceros. There are some cute comments like, after one guy says “I miss you,” the other says, “You can always visit me at me.com, sweetheart.” There’s even a page about being programmed by Starbucks. Check this thing out; it’s totally weird and cute. Man Must Eat (Reviewed by Marc) #3. St. Valentine’s Day Special. It’s like they decided to make this themed issue a week into the month of February. Really, there is always next year. ’Tis a shame, too, because an absence of development spoils a mean-spirited and fabulous idea: submitting ads to an online dating service for Sylvia Plath, Buster Keaton, and Marie Curie, complete with pics. (Matt even uses my favorite shot of Plath, the one where she’s reading in a sleeveless white sweater. You know, with the belt and lipstick? That one.) Unfortunately, there are all of two replies, and only one is good for the mocking. (A “creepy, lecherous, tattoo artist” from Tennessee liked the same photo of Mrs. Ted Hughes as I.) A few pages are filled with sheet music, printed sideways, which I assume to be (a) cut-and-paste backgrounds for a story never written or (b) an invitation to those with perfect pitch — exclusively — to enjoy a little Beethoven. Contains photos of the author. [free / digest / 28 pp. / photocopied, colored cover] Website: www.proxiepub.com/mme The Match (Reviewed by The J Man) #99, Winter 2002-2003: Cranky anarchist journal published by hothead old man Fred Woodworth has been around for 33 years, making it twice as old as 90% of the people who publish zines. The Match has a great reputation in zinedom Mr. Peebody’s Picture Book of Memories (Reviewed by Marc) v2, January 2003. Cartoons by people who cannot draw all that well are so telling. Jay’s father just happens to be the one who coined the moment with “Peebody”, don’t ya know, and here he is, staring ahead and without expression in a motorboat, as his son worries about alligators. Illustrated tales of childhood, put as simply as possible. The type is fuzzy and the paste-up is pretty rough, which brings to mind Arthur Janov (or, if you prefer, John Lennon’s Plastic Ono Band album). Unable to master, in one afternoon, the throwing of a hatchet he got for Christmas, thirteen-year-old Jay runs around massacring pine trees. You should see how he draws his eyes in that one. [50¢ / mini / 12 pp. / computer-printed, colored cover] Mr. Peebody’s Soiled Trousers And Other Delights (Reviewed by The J Man) #16: Diary zine from Jay, who used to be a chronic bed-wetter (hence the Mr. Peebody bit from the title) Pink Buffalo (Reviewed by thrill racer) #1, Summer 2002: This zine is put out by “a conglomerate of artists and activists in and around the University of Oklahoma.” A lot of the articles apply only to people who attend UO, but not all. The first article is all about Indymedia, a web page that lets activists do the reporting. The next is an article about how Starbucks serves dairy from “rBGH-injected cows” and how they exploit coffee bean farmers. I just don’t know why so many people insist on keeping Starbucks in business. Is the coffee really worth all the money people give them? I have a beverage right now, Cafix, which isn’t even coffee, but I think it’s totally good. Ingredients: Malted barley, barley, chicory, figs, and beet roots. Product of Switzerland. Yum! I’m glad this zine is taking note of cow rape, but unfortunately, the recipe section doesn’t actually reflect this view (only a couple of the recipes were vegan.) ¶ The zine also has poems, creative writing, and articles on other political issues such as abortion, race, sexuality, and tuition hikes. The author of “Why the Tuition Hike?”, Mike Wright, should’ve explained who Boren was (like I said earlier, a lot of the writing is geared only for those who live in Oklahoma.) In conclusion, I think the articles in this zine are worthwhile reading, but the writing needs to be polished and geared towards a more universal audience, plus there should be an introduction to orient the reader as to what the zine is about. The Pornographic Flabbergasted Emus (Reviewed by Marc) #2. Three chapters in this second installment of a novel about a garage band. It’s pretty good. To quote the back cover: “This is not really pornographic but does contain language such as the word ‘spiffy’ which may offend some readers.” The scene where the drummer of The Emus visits a XXX video shop coulda very well starred someone from your half-assed rock band in college; same goes for his semi-lesbian, teen-aged sidekick, whom he meets in Bible study. Not nearly as lazily written as it leads you to believe. I’m getting impatient for the next one. [$3 / digest / 48 pp. / photocopied, colored cardstock cover] Restoring Harmony (Reviewed by The J Man) #13, 12 Oct 02 - 12 Dec 02: Chick personal zine. These things are difficult to review, because they aren’t really about anything except the author’s obsessive need to expose them self to anybody and everybody. Most of these things put me in mind of skanky strippers: “For God’s sake, put some makeup on those bruises!” Are these things worth reading? Sure, but not for the reasons the author would hope (that you will admire them and write them fan mail to encourage their monstrous narcissism). You read these things out of voyeuristic curiosity, with a morbid admiration for the author’s unpasteurized exhibitionism. For example, Kerri, the author of this particular *perzine,* confesses her desire “to do for poetry what Madonna has done for music” Retail Whore (Reviewed by Marc) #7. First of all, I must say it is not fair in the least that this zine — which is exactly the same size and weight as my own — made it to me on one first-class stamp, because I know it requires eighty-three cents. Second, how come I’m only finding out now that there is a Scaredy-Cat Stalker website? Seriously, do not trust zine people when they say it’s their last issue. Now I’m five years behind. Scatological Think Cap (Reviewed by The J Man) #1: Yet another poop zine. If you want to know how many pounds of compacted feces were pulled out of John Wayne’s anus when he died, or if you want to know what it feels like to have thirty gallons of water flushed through your colon, or if you want to know the most bowel movement-friendly position to take on the crapper, then, as they say, this is the zine for you. But if (for some strange reason) you aren’t all that fascinated by human waste, then you might want to take something else to read on your next trip to the shitter. Second Guess (Reviewed by Marc) #16, Summer/Fall 2001. Hey, I’m fairly bright. At the age of twenty-four, I did give myself a tattoo, sure, but in the same week I was invited to join Mensa. I am not ashamed at all that I did not get (and, therefore, did not read) a good portion of this. Bob Conrad is a middle-aged anarchist type with a defunct punk band and a Master’s in Education, and what a shame he wasn’t born 15,000 years ago. A vegetarian with a panache for quoting anthropologists, he makes like he would rather be living with the pre-Americans as they took to farming, but I don’t buy it. Who, then, would he impress by treating the word “media” as a plural? There’s a lot about animism (you know, how all living things have a soul) and a lot about vegetarianism, which Bob actually faults for sustaining more humans per acre than non-vegetarian culture. ’Cuz then you gotta worry about overpopulation! The back cover of this handsomely printed and trimmed zine reads, “Imagine 13 Billion Humans by Y3K”. Dense prose, and without reward. Sample this from an article allegedly about Nick Broomfield’s Kurt and Courtney: “As we know from living in, but rarely acknowledging the profundities of, an analog world, black and white are extremes. Slug and Lettuce (Reviewed by thrill racer) #73: This is the second time I’ve read a copy of
S & L and that was years ago and look, it’s still going strong. This
is a newsprint 10,000 print run zine “supporting the do-it-yourself
ethics of the punk community.” When I think of punks I generally think of
tattooed alcoholics and chain smokers, but I was impressed to see that
this zine doesn’t glorify alcoholism in the slightest. Instead the
themes revolve around anarchism, alternative parenting, and even veganism
which is right on because I’m a vegan as well. Oddly enough, when I
first decided to go vegan about 10 years ago it was a punk (Dave from
Tiltwheel) who tried to discourage me and told me I’d “fall off the
wagon.” What an idiot. I guess he didn’t know me very well (even though he
was penning punk anthems about me.) Anyway, as the cover says, this
zine features “music, zine & book reviews, classifieds, columns,
photography, and punk art.” The zine and music review sections are massive and
I couldn’t even finish reading the music reviews (which were mostly of
punk/hardcore recordings) because it just became too overwhelming. My
fave column was by Adrienne, who wrote a “Eulogy” mourning the death of
a friendship (“I never deserved to have to live through your death.”)
The editor, Christine, wrote her usual intro essay (this time she talks
a lot about Richmond, VA) and tons of the reviews. Check it out. Slush Pile: the Second Coming! (Reviewed by Marc) O.K., let’s get this over with. I’ve been putting off reviewing this literary zine for a week. Mixed emotions are involved. So this is the Underground Literary Alliance, a group all in a huff because bourgeois authors like Jonathan Franzen, Rick Moody, and Susan Minot rack up grants from the Guggenheim and National Endowment for the Arts. These grants are supposed to foot the living expenses of unknown artists, blah blah, but it is common for this year’s winner to serve on the board deciding next year’s recipient, and often they just happen to return a favor. (I.e., this time it’s Moody’s turn, then Franzen — but don’t worry, Eggers, we haven’t forgotten you.) Yeah yeah, this is a travesty. My problem with the U.L.A. is how they take it from here. The founder of the group, Karl Wenclas, has no contribution proper in this issue. (Although, I did review his fiction once for Zine World, which I found almost juvenile, and heavy-handed in its treatment of globalization; my comments, of course, earned an ugly letter from Karl.) Instead, he appears only in posts reprinted from the group’s online message board, where he tells of “crashing” various public readings by the authors I mention above. Yes, this is my problem with the U.L.A. Why debate when you can make underarm farting noises? “King” Wenclas is satisfied by his own booming voice, and success is measured in security personnel. Yeah, it doesn’t matter that all you managed to get off was, “Literature has become something stuck on a dusty shelf in a library!” I’m sure all those people who came out to see Elissa Schappell were impressed by the man escorted from the building. I’m sure they’ll check out your website and write their Congressman. (It’s not made exactly clear when we should expect the literary revolution.) Well, this I know: if any person in this zine gets a Guggenheim grant, I’m staging my own protest. Now, onto business Snackbar Confidential (Reviewed by thrill racer) “The Best of Our First Five Years”: This zine is
a collection of vintage advertisements of “food” products, restaurants,
movies, and other bargains such as toys and clothes. Other clippings
include a Woolworth Coffee Shop menu (nasty!) and “Real Letters From
Morons.” The editor also makes short witty commentary, descriptions, and
reviews. My fave illustration depicts the transformation of Sonny the
Cocoa Puffs bird. Remember he used to be “Cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs”?
Now, he’s no longer insane; his once sharp beak is rounded out and he
wears a cheesy baseball jacket. Yeah, when I was a kid I’d go for all
those sugary cereals with a prize in the box, but now that I’m older and
wiser I read ingredients and only buy natural vegan cereals. These
cereals do not need a manipulative character on the box. For example,
right now I have Organic Peanut Butter Panda Puffs and Organic Koala Crisp.
These cereal boxes simply depict real panda and koala bears. These
bears are not trying to convince the consumer of anything. Anyway, get
this zine if you want a blast from the past and tips on what to dig up
(if I see That Girl and Phil, an unauthorized biography of Marlo Thomas,
at a thrift shop I might get it and I’m always a sucker for cheesy
horror movies!) Sore (Reviewed by Marc) #14. Why do we write like this when we’re young? Why so many adverbs, and phrasings that come back to haunt? Even the well-read ones, like the fellows who make this zine — between the ages of seventeen and twenty-one, males should not be left unattended with this beautiful language of ours. I do not need to see quotes from the likes of Hermann Hesse, nor hear how you finally finished The Brothers Karamazov. Most enjoyable (and amazingly, because he refers to it twice as a “zine-within-a-zine”) is “Cultor version 1”, a reasonably focused journal by Taylor. The writing is still quite bad in places, but it’s more earnest, like soft spots on a baby’s head, rather than some interview with a public school teacher who likes punk. Zine reviews, music reviews, book reviews, and columns. Oh yeah, this looks exactly like MaximumRockandRoll. [$2 / digest / 48 pp. / newsprint] The Tale Teller’s: Gravedigger (Reviewed by thrill racer) Here’s a comic zine that captures the more sinister side of life. It’s about a necrophile gravedigger who gets pulled into hell where he is seduced by a group of women who then pull off their crotch veils to reveal huge male genitalia where they then proceed to rape the sick gravedigger (“There is no greater grief than to remember days of joy when misery is at hand.”) The drawings are very explicit as you can imagine. More nasty things happen to the gravedigger and he eventually gets out of hell leaving a gateway for more hell creatures and room for another “tale.” This is for people with sick minds! thoughtworm (Reviewed by thrill racer) #9, December 2002: This issue of thoughtworm, a personal
zine written by Sean Stewart, is an essay about the writer’s musical
history from listening to playing to watching music. While this type of
zine is right up my alley (my own zine is about the same stuff and
coincidentally, I also published #9 of my zine in December 2002 and
mentioned seeing Kill Me Tomorrow—which I didn’t care for, but Sean loved) I
feel I must make some complaints about the writing right up front. My
first complaint is that Sean switches from using “I” to a plural pronoun
such as “we” or “our” too abruptly causing the reader to have to either
double back or skip forward to find out who he is referring to. Here’s
an example: On page 15 in a paragraph about how he doesn’t play in a
band anymore he consistently used the pronoun “I” until he started a
sentence, “While we lived in Columbia...” Who is we? I didn’t find out
until page 19 when he started a paragraph, “Anyway, when Malinda and I
moved to Columbia...” Malinda is introduced in the beginning of the zine
as the person who did the very cute “hand screen-printed” covers and as
the person who boosted Sean’s confidence in his writing. He never does
say if she’s his girlfriend or wife. For all we know she could be his
all around buddy (I once knew a couple, Tim and Molly, who lived
together and claimed to be “just friends,” but everyone knew they were full
of it.) The point is, why hide the facts? Should the reader make
assumptions? And, my other complaint about the writing is also illustrated
in the above example; that whenever Sean mentions a city he doesn’t
include the state (which can be confusing because there exist cities of
the same name in different states!) For a good part of the zine he talks
about the bands he was involved with in the town of Blacksburg and no,
he didn’t say the state, although, since he also mentioned the college
he attended there, Virginia Tech, I guess the reader can put two and
two together and conclude that Blacksburg is in Virginia, but the only
Blacksburg I ever heard of is in South Carolina ’cos I used to have a pen
pal from there about ten years ago (hi Jim if you’re reading this!) ¶
Now for some commentary on the content of the writing. I totally
noticed some typical musicians’ attitudes in these stories. Like, isn’t it
typical for musicians to quit bands when they are afraid that someone
else in the band will steal the spotlight so they instead content
themselves by joining mediocre bands? Check out these sentences where Sean
names the “good and bad” of having a capable singer, Brett, in his first
band, Kevorkian Fundraiser: “Good, because I think he and Allen
carried the band due to the fact that they were the only ones with any
talent. But bad because it was his voice and his ideas that eventually
caused Chris and I to split up the band.” Allen was the drummer and when
Sean and Chris decided to form a “simple punk band” they also decided
they “didn’t need a super-talented drummer” either. I’m tired of
musicians who go out of their way to avoid talent. What’s the point? I know,
it’s about being a drunk. Sean then documents how his buddy Chris was
“too fucked up to play” and how their band’s “persona” was drinking. ¶
In conclusion, I think Sean should keep writing about music and
personal stories, but he should try to be more clear and honest. On the first
page he even said he did not want the writing to be “too raw and
personal.” Writing is about expressing yourself, not playing it safe. He
even cited Scout Finnegan, a zinester who didn’t want to tackle a
“difficult topic” in her zine (yes, I’ve seen the first issue of her zine,
Scout, and it was cute), as an inspiration. This is not the kind of role
model Sean needs. If he felt free to express himself in his writing he
might even delve deeper than just recounting events, he could tackle
more interesting issues, such as why a lot of punks want to make mediocre
music and get wasted all the time. Like, if their ambitions are so low
then why do they need to join a clique in order to accomplish them?
More intellectual type stuff like that. It would make for more
interesting reading. Zine World: A Reader’s Guide to the Underground Press (Reviewed by Marc) #18, Winter 2003. The review I posted last time says all you need to know. A new issue of Zine World is now available for order. Hundreds of reviews. A twelve-page supplement compensates for some grossly dated material (e.g., deadlines for two mailart projects listed have long expired), but I’m not one to mind. It is good to see that it’s being offset printed again. I have only begun to order from this and plod through the news and such, but Marc Mulay’s performance in the letters section already warrants my four dollars spent. If Jerianne and the staff — I like Emerson, Gordon, Sean and Malinda, and Susan — really do return to publishing “three/four” issues per year, I wholeheartedly suggest subscribing. [$4 / standard / 64 pp. / printed, colored cover] Website: www.undergroundpress.org |